
Welcome to the January 2009 Insurance Netletter.
In this issue:
- All-Risk Insurance
- Automobile insurance
- Commercial general liability insurance
- Policies & Insurance Contracts
Please contact Nigel Trevethan or any member of our Insurance Practice Group with any questions about the cases in our netletter. A version of this netletter is published twice per month on Quicklaw.
About this Newsletter
The Harper Grey LLP Insurance Netletter provides a monthly review of new cases and emerging issues in Canadian insurance law. These summaries are not legal opinions. Readers should not act on the basis of these summaries without first consulting a lawyer for analysis and advice on a specific matter.
All-Risk Insurance
All-risk insurance - Policies and insurance contracts - Interpretation of policy - Coverage - Exclusions - Earth settlement; Property insurance - Soil movement
In an all-risk property insurance policy "settlement exclusion" excludes earth settlement caused by natural causes only
Automobile insurance
Automobile insurance - Coverage - Ownership, use or operation of motor vehicle - Negligent supervision of children
The father and grandfather of a five year old boy run over in a parking lot were unsuccessful in their action against the father's motor vehicle insurer where the Court held that the accident did not involve the "use or ownership" of the vehicle.
Commercial general liability insurance
Commercial general liability insurance - Wrongful dismissal - Duty to defend - Interpretation of policy - Costs - Apportionment of defence costs - Legal fees - Rights and duties of insurer - Third party claims
The Appeal by an insurer from an allocation of 95% of the costs of the insured's defence in a wrongful dismissal and malicious prosecution action to the insurer was dismissed where the court held that incidental assistance that the defence of the covered claim provided for the uncovered claim was not relevant to the determination of the insurer's liability for costs incurred by the insured for the defence of the claim.
Policies & Insurance Contracts
Policies and insurance contracts - Breach of policy - Coverage; Practice - Amending pleadings - Third parties - Adding a party - Limitation of actions - Running of limitation period - Discoverability - Statutory provisions
Farm Credit Canada ("FCC") was successful in its application for an order adding it as a plaintiff to an action against an insurer where the Court found that FCC was first loss payee on certain loans made to the original plaintiff and held that FCC's breach of contract claim was not statute-barred.
For comments or suggestions, please contact:
| Nigel L. Trevethan Insurance Law Group Chair Harper Grey LLP Barristers & Solicitors |
t: 604.895.2821 |







