Posts categorized Administrative Law Blog

Visit our Knowledge Centre for more searching.

The application for judicial review of a Provincial Court Judge’s decision was dismissed; the Court refused to allow the petitioner to argue an issue it overlooked raising in the underlying proceeding
The application for judicial review of a Provincial Court Judge’s decision was dismissed; the Court refused to allow the petitioner to argue an issue it overlooked raising in the underlying proceeding Administrative Law Blog The application for judicial review of a Provincial Court Judge’s decision was dismissed; the Court refused to allow the petitioner to argue an issue it overlooked raising in the underlying proceeding by JoAnne Barnum
April 25, 2024
“In approaching assertions of Cabinet confidentiality, administrative decision makers and reviewing courts must be attentive not only to the vital importance of public access to government-held information but also to Cabinet secrecy’s core purpose of enabling effective government, and its underlying rationales of efficiency, candour, and solidarity.” – Justice Karakatsanis writing for the majority
“In approaching assertions of Cabinet confidentiality, administrative decision makers and reviewing courts must be attentive not only to the vital importance of public access to government-held information but also to Cabinet secrecy’s core purpose of enabling effective government, and its underlying rationales of efficiency, candour, and solidarity.” – Justice Karakatsanis writing for the majority Administrative Law Blog “In approaching assertions of Cabinet confidentiality, administrative decision makers and reviewing courts must be attentive not only to the vital importance of public access to government-held information but also to Cabinet secrecy’s core purpose of enabling effective government, and its underlying rationales of efficiency, candour, and solidarity.” – Justice Karakatsanis writing for the majority by Aynsley Severide
March 19, 2024
An individual board member may disclose confidential board information to their own lawyer on matters affecting them personally
An individual board member may disclose confidential board information to their own lawyer on matters affecting them personally Administrative Law Blog An individual board member may disclose confidential board information to their own lawyer on matters affecting them personally by Joel A. Morris*
March 5, 2024
Judicial Review is not a venue for vindication
Judicial Review is not a venue for vindication Administrative Law Blog Judicial Review is not a venue for vindication by Deanna Froese
February 27, 2024
Veterinarian guilty of unprofessional conduct for non-compliant hydromorphone use
Veterinarian guilty of unprofessional conduct for non-compliant hydromorphone use Administrative Law Blog Veterinarian guilty of unprofessional conduct for non-compliant hydromorphone use by Ellie Einarson
February 27, 2024
A party may raise a procedural fairness issue for the first time on judicial review where that party could not reasonably have identified and raised the issue before the original decision-maker
A party may raise a procedural fairness issue for the first time on judicial review where that party could not reasonably have identified and raised the issue before the original decision-maker Administrative Law Blog A party may raise a procedural fairness issue for the first time on judicial review where that party could not reasonably have identified and raised the issue before the original decision-maker by Emilie LeDuc
January 30, 2024
The next time Vancouver’s Fire Chief seeks to remove the shelters the occupants of Hastings Block erect, procedural fairness demands that notice of this plan and an opportunity for the occupants to provide submissions to the Fire Chief must be provided
The next time Vancouver’s Fire Chief seeks to remove the shelters the occupants of Hastings Block erect, procedural fairness demands that notice of this plan and an opportunity for the occupants to provide submissions to the Fire Chief must be provided Administrative Law Blog The next time Vancouver’s Fire Chief seeks to remove the shelters the occupants of Hastings Block erect, procedural fairness demands that notice of this plan and an opportunity for the occupants to provide submissions to the Fire Chief must be provided by Renée Gagnon
January 30, 2024
Ontario Superior Court of Justice finds School Board appropriately balanced public member’s Charter right to freedom of expression with its bylaws in its decision to prevent further presentation on topics that it deemed could violate human rights legislation and its policies
Ontario Superior Court of Justice finds School Board appropriately balanced public member’s Charter right to freedom of expression with its bylaws in its decision to prevent further presentation on topics that it deemed could violate human rights legislation and its policies Administrative Law Blog Ontario Superior Court of Justice finds School Board appropriately balanced public member’s Charter right to freedom of expression with its bylaws in its decision to prevent further presentation on topics that it deemed could violate human rights legislation and its policies by Renée Gagnon
January 30, 2024
Utilities Commission breached its duty of procedural fairness when making a significant policy change without adequate notice of that potential change
Utilities Commission breached its duty of procedural fairness when making a significant policy change without adequate notice of that potential change Administrative Law Blog Utilities Commission breached its duty of procedural fairness when making a significant policy change without adequate notice of that potential change by Scott J. Marcinkow*
December 27, 2023
No breach of procedural fairness where a lawyer had an opportunity to provide submissions on costs, but did not do so
No breach of procedural fairness where a lawyer had an opportunity to provide submissions on costs, but did not do so Administrative Law Blog No breach of procedural fairness where a lawyer had an opportunity to provide submissions on costs, but did not do so by Scott J. Marcinkow*
December 27, 2023
Fishing association did not have standing to advance argument that Minister of Fisheries and Oceans breached its constitutional duty to consult with Indigenous stakeholders before making decision to geographically divide a lobster fishing area in Atlantic Ocean
Fishing association did not have standing to advance argument that Minister of Fisheries and Oceans breached its constitutional duty to consult with Indigenous stakeholders before making decision to geographically divide a lobster fishing area in Atlantic Ocean Administrative Law Blog Fishing association did not have standing to advance argument that Minister of Fisheries and Oceans breached its constitutional duty to consult with Indigenous stakeholders before making decision to geographically divide a lobster fishing area in Atlantic Ocean by Kara Hill
December 27, 2023
Federal Court of Appeal upholds Federal Employment Board’s dismissal of a complaint that alleged abuse of authority in an internal appointment process
Federal Court of Appeal upholds Federal Employment Board’s dismissal of a complaint that alleged abuse of authority in an internal appointment process Administrative Law Blog Federal Court of Appeal upholds Federal Employment Board’s dismissal of a complaint that alleged abuse of authority in an internal appointment process by JoAnne Barnum
November 29, 2023
Application for judicial review of a human rights tribunal decision was dismissed because the tribunal’s decision showed a rational chain of analysis
Application for judicial review of a human rights tribunal decision was dismissed because the tribunal’s decision showed a rational chain of analysis Administrative Law Blog Application for judicial review of a human rights tribunal decision was dismissed because the tribunal’s decision showed a rational chain of analysis by JoAnne Barnum
November 29, 2023
Court enjoins administrative body from enforcing newly enacted rule pending outcome of judicial review
Court enjoins administrative body from enforcing newly enacted rule pending outcome of judicial review Administrative Law Blog Court enjoins administrative body from enforcing newly enacted rule pending outcome of judicial review by Joel A. Morris*
November 29, 2023
City of Toronto meets procedural fairness obligations under Fair Wage Policy
City of Toronto meets procedural fairness obligations under Fair Wage Policy Administrative Law Blog City of Toronto meets procedural fairness obligations under Fair Wage Policy by Joel A. Morris*
November 29, 2023
Judge upholds $500,000 penalty for failure to comply with the Container Trucking Act
Judge upholds $500,000 penalty for failure to comply with the Container Trucking Act Administrative Law Blog Judge upholds $500,000 penalty for failure to comply with the Container Trucking Act by Deanna Froese
November 29, 2023
When breaches of procedural fairness can be cured by a de novo appeal, there is no sound reason for a judicial review to consider issues arising from the procedural fairness of the decision at first instance
When breaches of procedural fairness can be cured by a de novo appeal, there is no sound reason for a judicial review to consider issues arising from the procedural fairness of the decision at first instance Administrative Law Blog When breaches of procedural fairness can be cured by a de novo appeal, there is no sound reason for a judicial review to consider issues arising from the procedural fairness of the decision at first instance by Renée Gagnon
October 20, 2023
A professional’s Charter right to freedom of expression falls short against his professional obligations in protecting him from undergoing mandatory training to remediate his public statements
A professional’s Charter right to freedom of expression falls short against his professional obligations in protecting him from undergoing mandatory training to remediate his public statements Administrative Law Blog A professional’s Charter right to freedom of expression falls short against his professional obligations in protecting him from undergoing mandatory training to remediate his public statements by Renée Gagnon
October 20, 2023
The Respondent, a pharmacist, had his license cancelled by the Appellant College of Pharmacists. The pharmacist successfully appealed this decision to a judge of the Manitoba Court of Queen’s Bench. The College was unsuccessful in appealing the judge’s decision to the Manitoba Court of Appeal
The Respondent, a pharmacist, had his license cancelled by the Appellant College of Pharmacists. The pharmacist successfully appealed this decision to a judge of the Manitoba Court of Queen’s Bench. The College was unsuccessful in appealing the judge’s decision to the Manitoba Court of Appeal Administrative Law Blog The Respondent, a pharmacist, had his license cancelled by the Appellant College of Pharmacists. The pharmacist successfully appealed this decision to a judge of the Manitoba Court of Queen’s Bench. The College was unsuccessful in appealing the judge’s decision to the Manitoba Court of Appeal by Scott J. Marcinkow*
September 27, 2023
The applicant/appellant physician, Dr. Fialkov, was unsuccessful in seeking judicial review of a decision made by the Health Services Appeal and Review Board (HPARB). The HPARB dismissed Dr. Fialkov’s appeal from a decision of the Ministry of Health. The Ministry had decided that Dr. Fialkov improperly charged a patient for an insured service
The applicant/appellant physician, Dr. Fialkov, was unsuccessful in seeking judicial review of a decision made by the Health Services Appeal and Review Board (HPARB). The HPARB dismissed Dr. Fialkov’s appeal from a decision of the Ministry of Health. The Ministry had decided that Dr. Fialkov improperly charged a patient for an insured service Administrative Law Blog The applicant/appellant physician, Dr. Fialkov, was unsuccessful in seeking judicial review of a decision made by the Health Services Appeal and Review Board (HPARB). The HPARB dismissed Dr. Fialkov’s appeal from a decision of the Ministry of Health. The Ministry had decided that Dr. Fialkov improperly charged a patient for an insured service by Scott J. Marcinkow*
September 27, 2023
The Law Society of Ontario can refuse a licence application after the licence has already been issued where the applicant made a false or misleading representation on the application
The Law Society of Ontario can refuse a licence application after the licence has already been issued where the applicant made a false or misleading representation on the application Administrative Law Blog The Law Society of Ontario can refuse a licence application after the licence has already been issued where the applicant made a false or misleading representation on the application by Emilie LeDuc
September 27, 2023
Airbnb succeeds in quashing IPC’s order concerning public disclosure of Vancouver hosts’ personal addresses as potential risks of disclosure not reasonably considered
Airbnb succeeds in quashing IPC’s order concerning public disclosure of Vancouver hosts’ personal addresses as potential risks of disclosure not reasonably considered Administrative Law Blog Airbnb succeeds in quashing IPC’s order concerning public disclosure of Vancouver hosts’ personal addresses as potential risks of disclosure not reasonably considered by Kara Hill
August 29, 2023
Procedural Fairness in Reconsideration Decisions
Procedural Fairness in Reconsideration Decisions Administrative Law Blog Procedural Fairness in Reconsideration Decisions by Ellie Einarson
August 29, 2023
Court addresses application of principles governing judicial discipline
Court addresses application of principles governing judicial discipline Administrative Law Blog Court addresses application of principles governing judicial discipline by Joel A. Morris*
July 25, 2023
BC Court of Appeal upholds Supreme Court decision to protect implied undertaking to the court
BC Court of Appeal upholds Supreme Court decision to protect implied undertaking to the court Administrative Law Blog BC Court of Appeal upholds Supreme Court decision to protect implied undertaking to the court by Renée Gagnon
July 25, 2023
The Ontario Superior Court of Justice reasserts that save for rare and exceptional cases, judicial reviews will be rejected as premature when brought in the middle of administrative proceedings
The Ontario Superior Court of Justice reasserts that save for rare and exceptional cases, judicial reviews will be rejected as premature when brought in the middle of administrative proceedings Administrative Law Blog The Ontario Superior Court of Justice reasserts that save for rare and exceptional cases, judicial reviews will be rejected as premature when brought in the middle of administrative proceedings by Renée Gagnon
July 25, 2023
The Applicant, a Justice of the Peace, unsuccessfully sought judicial review of a decision from the Respondent, Justices of the Peace Review Council. The Council found her guilty of judicial misconduct and recommended that she be removed from judicial office Administrative Law Blog The Applicant, a Justice of the Peace, unsuccessfully sought judicial review of a decision from the Respondent, Justices of the Peace Review Council. The Council found her guilty of judicial misconduct and recommended that she be removed from judicial office by Scott J. Marcinkow*
June 20, 2023
The BC Human Rights Tribunal successfully appealed a decision of the BC Supreme Court and, in doing so, changed the legal test for family status discrimination in BC Administrative Law Blog The BC Human Rights Tribunal successfully appealed a decision of the BC Supreme Court and, in doing so, changed the legal test for family status discrimination in BC by Scott J. Marcinkow*
June 20, 2023
Municipalities permitted to restrict occupation by owners of rental units
Municipalities permitted to restrict occupation by owners of rental units Administrative Law Blog Municipalities permitted to restrict occupation by owners of rental units by Deanna Froese
June 20, 2023
Landlord who failed to move into her condo after evicting her tenant due to a change of moving plans arising out of the COVID-19 pandemic was ordered to pay the tenant a full year’s rent in compensation
Landlord who failed to move into her condo after evicting her tenant due to a change of moving plans arising out of the COVID-19 pandemic was ordered to pay the tenant a full year’s rent in compensation Administrative Law Blog Landlord who failed to move into her condo after evicting her tenant due to a change of moving plans arising out of the COVID-19 pandemic was ordered to pay the tenant a full year’s rent in compensation by Kara Hill
May 16, 2023
HRT’s decision to summarily dismiss complaint set aside in part because of its failure to consider new medical evidence about complainant’s diagnosis that had been provided after the employer’s impugned decisions had been made
HRT’s decision to summarily dismiss complaint set aside in part because of its failure to consider new medical evidence about complainant’s diagnosis that had been provided after the employer’s impugned decisions had been made Administrative Law Blog HRT’s decision to summarily dismiss complaint set aside in part because of its failure to consider new medical evidence about complainant’s diagnosis that had been provided after the employer’s impugned decisions had been made by Kara Hill
May 16, 2023
Decision by the Health Professions Review Board was set aside on the basis that the panel chair’s findings on the adequacy of the underlying investigation were patently unreasonable and the registrar’s underlying dispositions were reasonable
Decision by the Health Professions Review Board was set aside on the basis that the panel chair’s findings on the adequacy of the underlying investigation were patently unreasonable and the registrar’s underlying dispositions were reasonable Administrative Law Blog Decision by the Health Professions Review Board was set aside on the basis that the panel chair’s findings on the adequacy of the underlying investigation were patently unreasonable and the registrar’s underlying dispositions were reasonable by JoAnne Barnum
May 16, 2023
Landlord and Tenant Board’s decision to order a de novo hearing following the departure of their panel member was procedurally unfair in the circumstances
Landlord and Tenant Board’s decision to order a de novo hearing following the departure of their panel member was procedurally unfair in the circumstances Administrative Law Blog Landlord and Tenant Board’s decision to order a de novo hearing following the departure of their panel member was procedurally unfair in the circumstances by JoAnne Barnum
May 16, 2023
Judicial review of a decision of the Civil Resolution Tribunal (“CRT”) in the exercise of its jurisdiction over strata property disputes
Judicial review of a decision of the Civil Resolution Tribunal (“CRT”) in the exercise of its jurisdiction over strata property disputes Administrative Law Blog Judicial review of a decision of the Civil Resolution Tribunal (“CRT”) in the exercise of its jurisdiction over strata property disputes by Deanna Froese
April 18, 2023
Mayor eventually defeats the council members’ effort to replace her as chair of meetings Administrative Law Blog Mayor eventually defeats the council members’ effort to replace her as chair of meetings by Scott J. Marcinkow*
April 18, 2023
Denied again – BC Court of Appeal dismisses second appeal from CRT decision Administrative Law Blog Denied again – BC Court of Appeal dismisses second appeal from CRT decision by Scott J. Marcinkow*
April 18, 2023
Exceptional circumstances required for court to intervene in administration proceeding before it is completed
Exceptional circumstances required for court to intervene in administration proceeding before it is completed Administrative Law Blog Exceptional circumstances required for court to intervene in administration proceeding before it is completed by Joel A. Morris*
April 18, 2023
Government compliance with the reporting requirements under the Climate Change Accountability Act, S.B.C. 2007, c. 42 is justiciable
Government compliance with the reporting requirements under the Climate Change Accountability Act, S.B.C. 2007, c. 42 is justiciable Administrative Law Blog Government compliance with the reporting requirements under the Climate Change Accountability Act, S.B.C. 2007, c. 42 is justiciable by Emilie LeDuc
March 21, 2023
The Province does not need to prove fire control efforts were necessary or effective to recover such costs under the Wildfire Act
The Province does not need to prove fire control efforts were necessary or effective to recover such costs under the Wildfire Act Administrative Law Blog The Province does not need to prove fire control efforts were necessary or effective to recover such costs under the Wildfire Act by Emilie LeDuc
March 21, 2023
BC Supreme Court finds that if an administrative decision-maker is going to veer off its typical course in a decision, it needs to provide sufficient reasons to explain and justify its departure from the norm
BC Supreme Court finds that if an administrative decision-maker is going to veer off its typical course in a decision, it needs to provide sufficient reasons to explain and justify its departure from the norm Administrative Law Blog BC Supreme Court finds that if an administrative decision-maker is going to veer off its typical course in a decision, it needs to provide sufficient reasons to explain and justify its departure from the norm by Renée Gagnon
February 21, 2023
Make sure there is a connecting theme between events, before trying to argue the last in the series of events extends a filing deadline, or you might be disappointed
Make sure there is a connecting theme between events, before trying to argue the last in the series of events extends a filing deadline, or you might be disappointed Administrative Law Blog Make sure there is a connecting theme between events, before trying to argue the last in the series of events extends a filing deadline, or you might be disappointed by Renée Gagnon
February 21, 2023
Judicial Review of Business Licensing Decision
Judicial Review of Business Licensing Decision Administrative Law Blog Judicial Review of Business Licensing Decision by Ellie Einarson
January 17, 2023
Court of Appeal finds gathering & events public health orders justified under Charter
Court of Appeal finds gathering & events public health orders justified under Charter Administrative Law Blog Court of Appeal finds gathering & events public health orders justified under Charter by Roshni Veerapen
January 17, 2023
University Held to Task on Procedural Fairness
University Held to Task on Procedural Fairness Administrative Law Blog University Held to Task on Procedural Fairness by Roshni Veerapen
January 17, 2023
Physician’s application for review of the College’s decision to first restrict her practice then suspend her was dismissed. The physician’s patients were held to not have standing in the proceedings and a publication ban over certain information was granted
Physician’s application for review of the College’s decision to first restrict her practice then suspend her was dismissed. The physician’s patients were held to not have standing in the proceedings and a publication ban over certain information was granted Administrative Law Blog Physician’s application for review of the College’s decision to first restrict her practice then suspend her was dismissed. The physician’s patients were held to not have standing in the proceedings and a publication ban over certain information was granted by JoAnne Barnum
December 20, 2022
Court of Appeal upheld Mental Health Review Board’s decision that the petitioner continued to meet the criteria for involuntary detention under the Mental Health Act
Court of Appeal upheld Mental Health Review Board’s decision that the petitioner continued to meet the criteria for involuntary detention under the Mental Health Act Administrative Law Blog Court of Appeal upheld Mental Health Review Board’s decision that the petitioner continued to meet the criteria for involuntary detention under the Mental Health Act by JoAnne Barnum
December 20, 2022
Court of Appeal agrees it was not patently unreasonable for BC Human Rights Tribunal to summarily dismiss appellant’s discrimination complaint following his termination for using dating apps to hook up with male students on campus where he worked
Court of Appeal agrees it was not patently unreasonable for BC Human Rights Tribunal to summarily dismiss appellant’s discrimination complaint following his termination for using dating apps to hook up with male students on campus where he worked Administrative Law Blog Court of Appeal agrees it was not patently unreasonable for BC Human Rights Tribunal to summarily dismiss appellant’s discrimination complaint following his termination for using dating apps to hook up with male students on campus where he worked by Kara Hill
November 15, 2022
Small claims action dismissed after claimant’s failure to appear at settlement conference due to not seeing the notice of settlement conference in the mail during its COVID-related closure. Application to set that dismissal order aside was brought several months later and dismissed due to claimant’s lack of diligence
Small claims action dismissed after claimant’s failure to appear at settlement conference due to not seeing the notice of settlement conference in the mail during its COVID-related closure. Application to set that dismissal order aside was brought several months later and dismissed due to claimant’s lack of diligence Administrative Law Blog Small claims action dismissed after claimant’s failure to appear at settlement conference due to not seeing the notice of settlement conference in the mail during its COVID-related closure. Application to set that dismissal order aside was brought several months later and dismissed due to claimant’s lack of diligence by Kara Hill
November 15, 2022
Administrative Law Blog Court of Appeal upholds Assessment Review Board’s decision on assessment of certain condominium rental properties October 18, 2022
Impossibility of Compliance Defence – Mount Polley’s attempt at avoiding contravention of its permit
Impossibility of Compliance Defence – Mount Polley’s attempt at avoiding contravention of its permit Administrative Law Blog Impossibility of Compliance Defence – Mount Polley’s attempt at avoiding contravention of its permit by Adam R. Way
October 18, 2022
The COVID-19 pandemic does not necessarily constitute “extenuating circumstances” under the Residential Tenancy Act
The COVID-19 pandemic does not necessarily constitute “extenuating circumstances” under the Residential Tenancy Act Administrative Law Blog The COVID-19 pandemic does not necessarily constitute “extenuating circumstances” under the Residential Tenancy Act by Deanna Froese
September 20, 2022
Independent claims for Charter relief cannot be brought by petition
Independent claims for Charter relief cannot be brought by petition Administrative Law Blog Independent claims for Charter relief cannot be brought by petition by Emilie LeDuc
September 20, 2022
The Supreme Court of Canada established a new category of cases to which the correctness standard of review applies
The Supreme Court of Canada established a new category of cases to which the correctness standard of review applies Administrative Law Blog The Supreme Court of Canada established a new category of cases to which the correctness standard of review applies by Emilie LeDuc
September 20, 2022
Administrative Law Blog Court dismisses appeal of physician seeking to overturn decision to not renew privileges August 16, 2022
Administrative Law Blog Court dismisses two appeals arguing that the LAT was biased and denied procedural fairness August 16, 2022
No Inordinate Delay for “Unbecoming” Saskatchewan Lawyer
No Inordinate Delay for “Unbecoming” Saskatchewan Lawyer Administrative Law Blog No Inordinate Delay for “Unbecoming” Saskatchewan Lawyer by Roshni Veerapen
August 16, 2022
Realtor’s Appeal of Suspension Backfires
Realtor’s Appeal of Suspension Backfires Administrative Law Blog Realtor’s Appeal of Suspension Backfires by Roshni Veerapen
August 16, 2022
Petition for judicial review struck as improper attack on administrative proceedings
Petition for judicial review struck as improper attack on administrative proceedings Administrative Law Blog Petition for judicial review struck as improper attack on administrative proceedings by Joel A. Morris*
July 19, 2022
Know your limits – review board cannot dictate process to College Administrative Law Blog Know your limits – review board cannot dictate process to College by Scott J. Marcinkow*
July 19, 2022
Two options to calculate compensation in lieu of reinstatement after unjust dismissal Administrative Law Blog Two options to calculate compensation in lieu of reinstatement after unjust dismissal by Scott J. Marcinkow*
July 19, 2022
Stay in your own lane: when asked to review a decision of an administrative tribunal, the Court ought to decline jurisdiction where there is another process available that is more appropriate to the adjudication of the claim
Stay in your own lane: when asked to review a decision of an administrative tribunal, the Court ought to decline jurisdiction where there is another process available that is more appropriate to the adjudication of the claim Administrative Law Blog Stay in your own lane: when asked to review a decision of an administrative tribunal, the Court ought to decline jurisdiction where there is another process available that is more appropriate to the adjudication of the claim by Mollie Clark
June 21, 2022
You make the rules, or else you have to play fair: a society is entitled to create its own procedures, and in doing so may violate some principles of natural justice, as long as it does so expressly in its bylaws
You make the rules, or else you have to play fair: a society is entitled to create its own procedures, and in doing so may violate some principles of natural justice, as long as it does so expressly in its bylaws Administrative Law Blog You make the rules, or else you have to play fair: a society is entitled to create its own procedures, and in doing so may violate some principles of natural justice, as long as it does so expressly in its bylaws by Mollie Clark
June 21, 2022
Administrative Law Blog Court upholds decision of the WCAT dismissing appeal for the failure to file claim application within the one-year limitation period June 21, 2022
Administrative Law Blog Court dismisses appeal from an LTB decision on the grounds that there was no procedural unfairness or injustice in the result June 21, 2022
Schooled by the BCSC for Prematurity
Schooled by the BCSC for Prematurity Administrative Law Blog Schooled by the BCSC for Prematurity by Roshni Veerapen
May 17, 2022
Disgruntled Strata Owner Takes a Loss
Disgruntled Strata Owner Takes a Loss Administrative Law Blog Disgruntled Strata Owner Takes a Loss by Roshni Veerapen
May 17, 2022
Small Town Politics Gone Astray – Mayor denied procedural fairness after veiled attempted by Council to censure
Small Town Politics Gone Astray – Mayor denied procedural fairness after veiled attempted by Council to censure Administrative Law Blog Small Town Politics Gone Astray – Mayor denied procedural fairness after veiled attempted by Council to censure by Adam R. Way
May 17, 2022
Freedom of religion not engaged in small-scale hydroelectric project Administrative Law Blog Freedom of religion not engaged in small-scale hydroelectric project by Scott J. Marcinkow*
April 19, 2022
One wrong word in a decision does not mean the decision was wrong Administrative Law Blog One wrong word in a decision does not mean the decision was wrong by Scott J. Marcinkow*
April 19, 2022
The Federal Court of Appeal reinforced that absurd results must be avoided when interpreting legislation
The Federal Court of Appeal reinforced that absurd results must be avoided when interpreting legislation Administrative Law Blog The Federal Court of Appeal reinforced that absurd results must be avoided when interpreting legislation by Deanna Froese
April 19, 2022
Administrative Law Blog City failed to balance the severity of the interference with Charter values against a policy on acceptable advertising when it relied on a national regulatory body to remove advertisements March 15, 2022
Administrative Law Blog Court upholds decision of the Human Rights Commissioner that concluded there was insufficient evidentiary basis to move the complaint to a tribunal hearing March 15, 2022
Court of Appeal confirms a municipal body’s interpretation of their statutory powers is reviewable on a reasonableness standard
Court of Appeal confirms a municipal body’s interpretation of their statutory powers is reviewable on a reasonableness standard Administrative Law Blog Court of Appeal confirms a municipal body’s interpretation of their statutory powers is reviewable on a reasonableness standard by Joel A. Morris*
March 15, 2022
Public Sector Integrity Commissioner of Canada’s decision to refuse investigation into Canadian embassy involvement in foreign mining operations and criminal activity reasonable Administrative Law Blog Public Sector Integrity Commissioner of Canada’s decision to refuse investigation into Canadian embassy involvement in foreign mining operations and criminal activity reasonable by Joel A. Morris*
March 15, 2022
No harm, no foul. Where a breach of procedural fairness has been established, the Court will not find there was a reviewable error unless the breach affected the outcome
No harm, no foul. Where a breach of procedural fairness has been established, the Court will not find there was a reviewable error unless the breach affected the outcome Administrative Law Blog No harm, no foul. Where a breach of procedural fairness has been established, the Court will not find there was a reviewable error unless the breach affected the outcome by Mollie Clark
February 22, 2022
I take it back! In certain circumstances, an administrative body can correct a breach in procedural fairness by reopening the relevant decision
I take it back! In certain circumstances, an administrative body can correct a breach in procedural fairness by reopening the relevant decision Administrative Law Blog I take it back! In certain circumstances, an administrative body can correct a breach in procedural fairness by reopening the relevant decision by Mollie Clark
February 22, 2022
The case of the missing dollar: Arbitrator’s decision found procedurally unfair after reversing burden of proof
The case of the missing dollar: Arbitrator’s decision found procedurally unfair after reversing burden of proof Administrative Law Blog The case of the missing dollar: Arbitrator’s decision found procedurally unfair after reversing burden of proof by Adam R. Way
February 22, 2022
Expression of preliminary findings by an administrative body does not necessarily indicate a reasonable apprehension of bias Administrative Law Blog Expression of preliminary findings by an administrative body does not necessarily indicate a reasonable apprehension of bias by Deanna Froese
January 25, 2022
Jurisdiction and process do matter; police sergeant wins case against the Police Complaint Commissioner Administrative Law Blog Jurisdiction and process do matter; police sergeant wins case against the Police Complaint Commissioner by Scott J. Marcinkow*
January 25, 2022
Administrative Law Blog Federal Court of Appeal upholds decision that the Minister of Health did not deny the appellant procedural fairness in refusing a natural health product license December 21, 2021
Administrative Law Blog BCSC upholds decision of the information and privacy commissioner denying assertions of privileges over certain documents December 21, 2021
Fair is fair: where statutory interpretation is the core issue decided upon following written and oral submissions, it is not procedurally unfair for the decision maker to rely on a particular term contained in the regulations being interpreted about which submissions were not specifically made
Fair is fair: where statutory interpretation is the core issue decided upon following written and oral submissions, it is not procedurally unfair for the decision maker to rely on a particular term contained in the regulations being interpreted about which submissions were not specifically made Administrative Law Blog Fair is fair: where statutory interpretation is the core issue decided upon following written and oral submissions, it is not procedurally unfair for the decision maker to rely on a particular term contained in the regulations being interpreted about which submissions were not specifically made by Mollie Clark
December 21, 2021
There are no shortcuts to judicial review: judicial review will not be available where there is an adequate alternative remedy. A limited right of appeal from decisions of an administrative body to the Court constitutes an adequate alternative remedy
There are no shortcuts to judicial review: judicial review will not be available where there is an adequate alternative remedy. A limited right of appeal from decisions of an administrative body to the Court constitutes an adequate alternative remedy Administrative Law Blog There are no shortcuts to judicial review: judicial review will not be available where there is an adequate alternative remedy. A limited right of appeal from decisions of an administrative body to the Court constitutes an adequate alternative remedy by Mollie Clark
December 21, 2021
Is a business licence being renewed, revoked or granted? Turns out it matters
Is a business licence being renewed, revoked or granted? Turns out it matters Administrative Law Blog Is a business licence being renewed, revoked or granted? Turns out it matters by Adam R. Way
December 21, 2021
Saskatchewan Court of Appeal holds University of Saskatchewan Council was bound by their own internal regulations and failure to follow the regulations in this instance lead to a finding of a denial of procedural fairness Administrative Law Blog Saskatchewan Court of Appeal holds University of Saskatchewan Council was bound by their own internal regulations and failure to follow the regulations in this instance lead to a finding of a denial of procedural fairness by Deanna Froese
November 16, 2021
Petitioners successfully sought judicial review of a decision made by the Agricultural Land Commission, which had refused a subdivision request Administrative Law Blog Petitioners successfully sought judicial review of a decision made by the Agricultural Land Commission, which had refused a subdivision request by Scott J. Marcinkow*
October 19, 2021
The respondent, Healthcare of Ontario Pension Plan (HOPP), made a successful application to quash the applicant’s application for judicial review Administrative Law Blog The respondent, Healthcare of Ontario Pension Plan (HOPP), made a successful application to quash the applicant’s application for judicial review by Scott J. Marcinkow*
October 19, 2021
Finding of professional misconduct reversed on basis that College failed to specific elements of allegation in citation Administrative Law Blog Finding of professional misconduct reversed on basis that College failed to specific elements of allegation in citation by Joel A. Morris*
October 19, 2021
Administrative Law Blog Residential Tenancy Branch decision failed to adequately articulate the reasons for its decision and the matter was remitted back to the Residential Tenancy Branch October 19, 2021
Administrative Law Blog Zoning Bylaw allows an automotive repair shop to store junked vehicles for the purposes of its business and parts inventory October 19, 2021
That’s reasonable, right? The standard of review regarding questions of procedural fairness met by an administrative decision maker is not correctness, but rather whether the standard of fairness required by the common law has been met
That’s reasonable, right? The standard of review regarding questions of procedural fairness met by an administrative decision maker is not correctness, but rather whether the standard of fairness required by the common law has been met Administrative Law Blog That’s reasonable, right? The standard of review regarding questions of procedural fairness met by an administrative decision maker is not correctness, but rather whether the standard of fairness required by the common law has been met by Mollie Clark
September 21, 2021
Reviewable Decisions – The conundrum of determining whether a decision is subject to judicial review Administrative Law Blog Reviewable Decisions – The conundrum of determining whether a decision is subject to judicial review by Adam R. Way
September 21, 2021
Court refuses application for review on reasonableness standard as applicant had not exhausted right of appeal under relevant legislation
Court refuses application for review on reasonableness standard as applicant had not exhausted right of appeal under relevant legislation Administrative Law Blog Court refuses application for review on reasonableness standard as applicant had not exhausted right of appeal under relevant legislation by JoAnne Barnum
September 21, 2021
College’s decision to terminate physician’s assessment was reasonable given concerns about patient safety
College’s decision to terminate physician’s assessment was reasonable given concerns about patient safety Administrative Law Blog College’s decision to terminate physician’s assessment was reasonable given concerns about patient safety by JoAnne Barnum
September 21, 2021
Government employee attacks internal hiring decision without success Administrative Law Blog Government employee attacks internal hiring decision without success by Scott J. Marcinkow*
August 17, 2021
Court upholds penalties for a City Councillor who sexually harassed a colleague Administrative Law Blog Court upholds penalties for a City Councillor who sexually harassed a colleague by Scott J. Marcinkow*
August 17, 2021
Administrative Law Blog Did the appellant “promptly and completely” reply to the Law Society of Ontario (respondent) during an investigation into the appellant’s law firm that focused on the firm’s structure and referral fee practices? July 20, 2021
Administrative Law Blog Prevented from being able to practice: Ontario Court allowed an appeal from a decision of the registration committee of the Ontario Association of Architects granting the appellant a license but refusing to reinstate his certificate of practice July 20, 2021
It’s all in the context: the content of hospital privileges and assessment of what constitutes constructive revocation of privileges is highly contextual, to be examined on a case by case basis
It’s all in the context: the content of hospital privileges and assessment of what constitutes constructive revocation of privileges is highly contextual, to be examined on a case by case basis Administrative Law Blog It’s all in the context: the content of hospital privileges and assessment of what constitutes constructive revocation of privileges is highly contextual, to be examined on a case by case basis by Mollie Clark
July 20, 2021
It’s all fair game: the scope of an investigation ordered pursuant to British Columbia Law Society Rule 4-55 encompasses a broad investigation of the member’s entire legal practice and is not limited to the concerns that triggered the investigation
It’s all fair game: the scope of an investigation ordered pursuant to British Columbia Law Society Rule 4-55 encompasses a broad investigation of the member’s entire legal practice and is not limited to the concerns that triggered the investigation Administrative Law Blog It’s all fair game: the scope of an investigation ordered pursuant to British Columbia Law Society Rule 4-55 encompasses a broad investigation of the member’s entire legal practice and is not limited to the concerns that triggered the investigation by Mollie Clark
July 20, 2021
Determination of internal standard of review of an administrative tribunal following Vavilov Administrative Law Blog Determination of internal standard of review of an administrative tribunal following Vavilov by Joel A. Morris*
July 20, 2021
Judicial review prior to conclusion of administrative proceeding not allowed on allegation of bias alone
Judicial review prior to conclusion of administrative proceeding not allowed on allegation of bias alone Administrative Law Blog Judicial review prior to conclusion of administrative proceeding not allowed on allegation of bias alone by JoAnne Barnum
May 18, 2021
Non-parties to an arbitration agreement were not bound by the agreement, but instead were bound by the Arbitration Act, 1991 S.O. 1991, c.17
Non-parties to an arbitration agreement were not bound by the agreement, but instead were bound by the Arbitration Act, 1991 S.O. 1991, c.17 Administrative Law Blog Non-parties to an arbitration agreement were not bound by the agreement, but instead were bound by the Arbitration Act, 1991 S.O. 1991, c.17 by JoAnne Barnum
May 18, 2021
Beyond the Supervisory Role – chambers judge fails to properly apply reasonableness standard by seeking to determine the “correct” test the Director of the Law Society should have applied Administrative Law Blog Beyond the Supervisory Role – chambers judge fails to properly apply reasonableness standard by seeking to determine the “correct” test the Director of the Law Society should have applied by Adam R. Way
May 18, 2021
Court rules public health order banning indoor religious gatherings are a justified infringement on Charter rights to freedom of religion and expression
Court rules public health order banning indoor religious gatherings are a justified infringement on Charter rights to freedom of religion and expression Administrative Law Blog Court rules public health order banning indoor religious gatherings are a justified infringement on Charter rights to freedom of religion and expression by Kara Hill
April 20, 2021
Human Rights Tribunal can refuse to accept complaints for filing if facts do not allege, beyond the realm of conjecture, a contravention of the Code
Human Rights Tribunal can refuse to accept complaints for filing if facts do not allege, beyond the realm of conjecture, a contravention of the Code Administrative Law Blog Human Rights Tribunal can refuse to accept complaints for filing if facts do not allege, beyond the realm of conjecture, a contravention of the Code by Kara Hill
April 20, 2021
Off duty conduct must be carefully assessed before concluding it warrants disciplinary action Administrative Law Blog Off duty conduct must be carefully assessed before concluding it warrants disciplinary action by Scott J. Marcinkow*
April 20, 2021
A principal’s isolated misconduct did not justify a demotion Administrative Law Blog A principal’s isolated misconduct did not justify a demotion by Scott J. Marcinkow*
April 20, 2021
Pump the brakes – sections 133(1)(b) and (c) of the Civil Resolutions Tribunal Act, S.B.C. 2012, c. 25 are declared unconstitutional and of no force and effect Administrative Law Blog Pump the brakes – sections 133(1)(b) and (c) of the Civil Resolutions Tribunal Act, S.B.C. 2012, c. 25 are declared unconstitutional and of no force and effect by Mollie Clark
April 20, 2021
It’s all relative – what it takes for a decision maker to discharge its duty of procedural fairness depends on a determination of the level of procedural fairness required in the specific circumstances Administrative Law Blog It’s all relative – what it takes for a decision maker to discharge its duty of procedural fairness depends on a determination of the level of procedural fairness required in the specific circumstances by Mollie Clark
April 20, 2021
Strained interpretation – standard of review applicable to the Civil Resolution Tribunal decision when it has “specialized expertise” Administrative Law Blog Strained interpretation – standard of review applicable to the Civil Resolution Tribunal decision when it has “specialized expertise” by Adam R. Way
March 16, 2021
Administrative Law Blog Court upholds revocation of physician’s licence after repeated care and conduct concerns over a lengthy period of time March 16, 2021
Administrative Law Blog Court dismisses taxi companies judicial review concerning decisions of the BC Passenger Transportation Board regarding ride sharing approvals of Uber and Lyft March 16, 2021
Municipal bylaws do not apply to activities authorized under permit issued under Mines Act because of exclusive provincial jurisdiction over “mines” and “mining activities” Administrative Law Blog Municipal bylaws do not apply to activities authorized under permit issued under Mines Act because of exclusive provincial jurisdiction over “mines” and “mining activities” by Joel A. Morris*
March 16, 2021
The standard of review for jurisdictional questions under the Manufactured Home Park Tenancy Act is patent unreasonableness Administrative Law Blog The standard of review for jurisdictional questions under the Manufactured Home Park Tenancy Act is patent unreasonableness by Deanna Froese
February 16, 2021
Reasonable for panel to sanction medical student for leaving medical records in a dumpster
Reasonable for panel to sanction medical student for leaving medical records in a dumpster Administrative Law Blog Reasonable for panel to sanction medical student for leaving medical records in a dumpster by JoAnne Barnum
February 16, 2021
Procedural fairness requires notice of potential timeliness issues Administrative Law Blog Procedural fairness requires notice of potential timeliness issues by JoAnne Barnum
February 16, 2021
Court confirms no breach of procedural fairness rights in party not being able to cross-examine witness when party had not specifically requested to do so
Court confirms no breach of procedural fairness rights in party not being able to cross-examine witness when party had not specifically requested to do so Administrative Law Blog Court confirms no breach of procedural fairness rights in party not being able to cross-examine witness when party had not specifically requested to do so by Kara Hill
January 19, 2021
Facts are facts – where an administrative body’s rules create a strict liability offence, the fact of the offence results in liability. There is no liability defence of due diligence available Administrative Law Blog Facts are facts – where an administrative body’s rules create a strict liability offence, the fact of the offence results in liability. There is no liability defence of due diligence available by Mollie Clark
January 19, 2021
You don’t get a second kick at the can – all evidence and issues one wishes to raise within administrative proceedings should be raised with the administrative decision-maker and may be disregarded by reviewing courts Administrative Law Blog You don’t get a second kick at the can – all evidence and issues one wishes to raise within administrative proceedings should be raised with the administrative decision-maker and may be disregarded by reviewing courts by Mollie Clark
January 19, 2021